Small Business Owners Say They Want to Hire. The Labor Data Is Not Convinced.

Share this Post:

NFIB’s September survey shows a net 17% of small business owners plan to increase employment over the next three months, unchanged from August and well above the long run average of net 11%. That reading sits at the strong end of the range plotted on the chart, where inverted hiring plans have tracked the unemployment rate closely for five decades. The Bureau of Labor Statistics, meanwhile, reported that unemployment ticked up to 4.2% in September from 4.1%, after payrolls rose by just 29,000 against expectations of roughly 90,000. When hiring intentions run this far ahead of the realized data, the gap itself becomes the story.

Beneath the headline, the NFIB survey shows intentions are not converting into action. The share of owners who actually hired or tried to hire fell 5 points to 51%, job openings dropped 3 points to 32%, and the NFIB Employment Index slipped 1.2 points to 100.6, below its 2025 average of 101.2. The constraint appears to be supply rather than demand: 45% of owners reported few or no qualified applicants, which is 87% of those trying to hire, and 26% named labor quality or availability as their single most important problem, more than double the historical average of 12%. Labor costs, by contrast, were cited as the top problem by just 6% of owners, the lowest share since December 2020. Employers want workers, but they cannot find the right ones at a price they are willing to pay.

The broader labor market data fits that description of a stalled, low churn economy. The BLS revised July and August payrolls down by a combined 60,000, and job growth has averaged about 68,000 per month this year, stronger than 2025 but well below pre pandemic norms. Unemployment has stayed in a narrow band of 4.1% to 4.3% since March, partly because the labor force is roughly one million smaller than it was a year ago, which lowers the number of jobs needed to hold the rate steady. After the September report, markets scaled back the odds of further Fed tightening this year, though inflation pressure and mortgage rates above 7% leave little room for the central bank to lean toward easing. A labor market that is neither collapsing nor tightening is an awkward fit for a Fed still worried about prices.

The chart carries a warning about how much weight to place on hiring plans alone. The two series move together over long stretches, but the relationship is loose in the short run, and the 2020 spike in unemployment arrived with little advance notice from survey intentions. NFIB’s Uncertainty Index sits at 90, far above its historical average of 68, and owners cite rising costs, higher interest rates, and the difficulty of finding qualified employees as reasons they are moving cautiously. If plans fail to convert into hires, unemployment can drift higher even with positive survey readings. If labor supply keeps growing slowly, unemployment could instead stay contained despite weak payroll growth, which would leave the headline rate a poor guide to underlying demand.

Disclosure

This material is provided by Gryphon Financial Partners, LLC (“Gryphon”) for informational purposes only. It is not intended as a substitute for personalized investment advice or as a recommendation or solicitation of any particular security, strategy, or investment product. Facts presented have been obtained from sources believed to be reliable, though Gryphon cannot guarantee their accuracy or completeness. Gryphon does not provide tax, accounting, or legal advice. Individuals should seek such guidance from qualified professionals based on their specific circumstances.

Have a Question About This Topic?

Share this post:

This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience.  Learn more