The NAHB/Wells Fargo Housing Market Index fell three points to 29 in October, its lowest reading since June 2012 and below the consensus forecast of 31. Anything under 50 means more builders view conditions as poor than good, and the index has now been below that line for most of the past four years. The chart makes the scale of the reversal plain: from a peak near 90 in late 2020, builder sentiment has dropped by roughly 60 points, and today’s level falls below even the brief pandemic plunge of April 2020. Only the stretch from 2007 to 2012 shows a weaker housing market through the eyes of the people building the homes.
All three components of the index declined. Current sales conditions fell two points to 33, expectations for sales over the next six months fell five points to 32, the weakest since November 2022, and prospective buyer traffic dropped five points to 18. Builders are responding with price. A record share for the 2020 to 2026 period, 43%, cut prices in October, up from 38% in September, while the average reduction held at 6% for a seventh straight month and 65% of builders used sales incentives. Regionally, the three month averages show the West at 26 and the South at 30, with the Northeast at 38 and the Midwest at 40, where single family permits are up 2.9%.
The macro drivers are rates and costs. Freddie Mac reported the 30 year fixed mortgage rate averaged 7.40% last week, its highest in nearly three years, and NAHB leadership pointed to higher gas prices and inflation as additional drags on buyer traffic. Builders are also contending with elevated material costs, tariffs, and labor expenses, with a separate NAHB survey showing builder labor costs up a median 4.2% over the past year. This puts housing at the center of the Fed’s dilemma: September payrolls rose by only 29,000 and unemployment moved up to 4.2%, which argues for patience, but persistent inflation keeps long term rates elevated and the mortgage market frozen. Weak labor data has not translated into relief for borrowers.
The tension is that today’s price cuts may be setting up tomorrow’s supply problem. Builders are the marginal source of new housing, and NAHB’s chief economist noted that demand persists but is being held back by affordability, so the shortfall is in transactions rather than need. Margin compression from discounts and rate buydowns tends to slow new starts over time, which would tighten supply just as rates eventually ease and keep shelter costs sticky. Weak builder sentiment also feeds through to residential investment and construction employment, two areas that often signal broader turning points before the rest of the economy follows. The next readings on housing starts, permits, and mortgage rates will show whether October’s 29 marks a trough or a waypoint.
Disclosure
This material is provided by Gryphon Financial Partners, LLC (“Gryphon”) for informational purposes only. It is not intended as a substitute for personalized investment advice or as a recommendation or solicitation of any particular security, strategy, or investment product. Facts presented have been obtained from sources believed to be reliable, though Gryphon cannot guarantee their accuracy or completeness. Gryphon does not provide tax, accounting, or legal advice. Individuals should seek such guidance from qualified professionals based on their specific circumstances.